Another title, the same old problems: What India’s SAFF dominance reveals

Pakistan threatened an upset, Bhutan challenged the champions and Bangladesh dared to dream. Yet a depleted India still claimed a record tenth SAFF Championship title. Behind another familiar result lies a more troubling story of South Asian football, where extraordinary passion and emerging talent remain undermined by weak domestic structures, instability and years of missed opportunities.

On Saturday evening, the courtyard of Hamza Choudhury’s family home in northeastern Bangladesh, as a local paper put it, became a mini stadium. Neighbours crowded around a screen to watch a man born in Loughborough wear the armband as Bangladesh set out aiming to secure their first South Asian Championship final berth since 2005. 

Afterall, the Sheffield United midfielder’s switching of allegiances has been nothing short of a rejuvenation for a country that, for six weeks every four years, attracts eyeballs for its borderline unhealthy obsession for Argentina. At home with Hamza at the helm, this surely was the year for everyone to ditch their adopted national team, located some 16,000 kilometres away, and drape the red and green. 

Except, it was not. With five minutes left, it was Abdul Samad, a Denmark-born and based forward who had joined Pakistan’s squad midweek, who made the lively National Stadium in Dhaka turn on itself. Passion turned ugly, the Bangladeshi captain had to step up to stop the flares that came over the fences. 

While hosts Bangladesh’s SAFF Championship story ended there, another picked pace. Pakistan, just 14 places from the bottom in FIFA rankings, were a step away from the title despite years marred with multiple FIFA suspensions and an absent domestic league. More impressive, the diaspora players who had flown in only once the FIFA window opened had pulled a squad together mid-tournament and carried it past the hosts. 

They were not the only ones either. Earlier that same day, Bhutan, ranked 192nd and playing their first SAFF semi-final in 18 years, had trailed India 2-0 at half-time and then spent the second half making the champions sweat, pulling one back through Kinzang Tashi Tobden and coming within inches of an equalizer.

However, the genuine novelty that SAFF had on its hands and the last possibility of a break from the routine lasted exactly three days. India, as India tend to at this level, clinched their third consecutive – and their record extending tenth – title. 

There is a version of Tuesday night that can be told as a triumph, and it is not untrue. In their first SAFF final, Pakistan led at half-time and looked to have things under control until a red card and a compelling effort saw India win it through Sandip Mandi’s 88th-minute header. 

As accurate as that version stands, it is in every way that matters, beside the point. Despite the Blue Colts’ head coach begging to differ, the Indian side that lifted the trophy was a depleted one, with only 17 players at its disposal and almost the entire first team away in New Zealand for a couple of international friendlies.

Credit where it is due, the on-paper second-string side were deserving winners, owing to the spirited performances throughout. Yet, that the trophy came home all the same, should sit as an uncomfortable detail for the rest of South Asia. 

Firstly, the depth of the region is not a matter of opinion. South Asia is home to more than a fifth of humanity, and not one of its countries has ever played at the men’s FIFA World Cup. Only two have reached the continental finals, as Bangladesh’s 1980 appearance remains the only bar India’s five. Neither will be in Saudi Arabia for the next one, as India’s chances went begging with a defeat against Singapore last year. The country hailed by multiple FIFA Presidents as global football’s sleeping giants has also stumbled and jammed somewhere along the way.

It has been exactly a year since Bangladesh secured a 1-0 win against India, their first against the neighbours in 23 years, in Dhaka. Twelve months on, a reserve side lifted a trophy on the same pitch, and it is definitely the latter that is emblematic of where South Asian football actually stands. 

The usual explanations for the state that South Asian football is in are often lazily attributed to everything from cricket’s dominant grip to poverty, or some vague absence of footballing culture. However, as comforting as those reasons seem on the face, they crumble on contact with the courtyard in Bangladesh, or with Kolkata on derby day. This year’s tournament was a testament to the fact that the appetite for football is plainly there. 

What has been missing is the patient, unglamorous work of turning it into something. While India’s own top flight could not start on time last season over sundry disputes, Pakistan’s has not been played since 2019, and Bangladesh’s domestic circuit also does not boast a holistic pyramid. Maldives’ federation has been run by a FIFA normalisation committee since 2024, with its former president serving a lifetime ban for misusing FIFA’s COVID relief funds. Nepal did not make it to Dhaka for the tournament at all, as the country’s footballing body has remained suspended by the global governing body since June, citing third-party government interference. 

The tournament’s organisation, too, was a quagmire. Initially slated to be held in Sri Lanka in July 2025, it was reportedly postponed for a more lucrative format. Current hosts Bangladesh were only announced once the sponsors were secured and dates were adjusted to take India in. When it finally began, it fell outside the FIFA window, resulting in overseas players missing the group stages. The region desperately needs leagues that start on time, grassroots programs that encourage talent development, federations that stay out of FIFA’s bad books, and a calendar the region sets for itself. 

In that light, perhaps the inspiring runs in the tournament were signs of what talent can do in spite of the existing system that has kept this region’s football at bay. It reflects on us a kind of uncomfortable certainty that India will keep winning SAFF for precisely as long as the region’s football stays the way it is. The day India lose this tournament, not to a late penalty or a lucky bounce, but to a neighbour that has quietly built a league and a pathway, may be the better for Indian football.

Until then, there is death, there are taxes, and there is India, lifting a trophy that tells us almost nothing we want to hear, in front of people who deserve a great deal more. 

Sudesh Baniya
Sudesh Baniya

Sudesh is a freelance football writer from Nepal based in Doha. He is currently a journalism student at Northwestern University and covers South Asian and Qatari football across the written word, audio, and video.

Articole: 8