The breakthrough that never came: Hajime Moriyasu’s complicated legacy

Eight years, historic victories over football's biggest nations and a Japan team transformed into genuine global contenders. Yet Hajime Moriyasu leaves without an Asian Cup title or a World Cup knockout victory. His legacy is one of remarkable progress, lingering tactical questions and the uncomfortable feeling that something greater was within reach.

It’s difficult to question that Hajime Moriyasu departs as Japanese head coach with the team in a stronger position than when he found it, with a generation of players capable of competing with the world’s best. Yet, for all the progress, significant hurdles remain, leaving a lingering question hanging over his ultimate legacy.

In the end, defeat to Paraguay in a understated friendly in front of crowd of less than 20,000 in Singapore, was how it finished, but there was something more fitting about Moriyasu’s final months in charge of Japan being bookended by two encounters with Brazil.

A 2-1 defeat in the last 32 of the World Cup in the summer, which denied the Samurai Blue a historic first knockout stage victory, was followed by last Saturday’s remarkable 3-2 friendly victory. To conclude eight years of his tenure, Moriyasu had secured a second victory from three over the five-time world champions, but it left most pining for the one that got away.

The latest victory was an almost perfect illustration of the manager’s time in charge. Japan have become increasingly capable of producing results against the world’s leading nations; having beaten every former World Cup champion he’s faced. For all the landmark victories and the progress made under his leadership, however, there remains a nagging feeling that Moriyasu leaves behind a team which has never quite fulfilled its potential.

Historic victories over Germany and Spain in Qatar, the statement triumph over England at Wembley and now two wins against Brazil will assure his impact on the national team will be long lasting, but with two consecutive World Cup knockout exits and no Asian Cup title to show for his efforts, the question of how his time in the job will be remembered is two-sided.

Changing  perceptions

By the time Moriyasu took charge in 2018, Japanese football was already undergoing a considerable evolution. An increasingly impressive collection of players were making their way into European football, while the development of the J.League and the country’s wider football infrastructure had helped establish a stronger foundation for the national team.

The 2022 World Cup provided the clearest indication of what was possible. Victories over Germany and Spain, both secured through disciplined defensive performances and devastating second-half breaks, announced Japan as a genuine threat to the established order. Their subsequent progress through qualifying for 2026, and a series of increasingly impressive results against elite opposition, reinforced an image that evolved from dark horses to credible contenders.

The emergence of players such as Kaoru Mitoma, Takefusa Kubo, Ritsu Doan and Daichi Kamada has helped transform the profile of the national team. Japan now possess a depth of European-based talent that break the long crude stereotype, of a squad fuil of hard workers.

Moriyasu deserves considerable credit for bringing these players together, establishing a collective identity and, perhaps most importantly, changing the expectations surrounding the national team. Japan no longer travel to face the likes of Brazil, Germany or England simply hoping to remain competitive. They expect to win. When they arrived in North America over the summer, players and officials alike were talking about winning the whole thing; a distinct shift in mentality, which Moriyasu should lay claim to.

The tactical ceiling

Yet beneath the impressive results, there have been recurring questions about whether Japan have always made the most of their considerable talents.

Moriyasu’s preference for a reactive approach was understandable in moments, as Japan’s ability to absorb pressure, remain compact and exploit the spaces left by opponents was central to their more memorable victories. The problem was that this approach occasionally became a limitation when Japan were expected to take the initiative themselves.

The defeat to Costa Rica in Qatar was perhaps the clearest example of this, offering little attacking substance and opportunity to break down an opponent they were expected to dominate. The subsequent knockout stage defeat to Croatia, in which they again struggled to impose themselves over 120 minutes, raised further questions about their ability to control knockout football.

There was a sense that Moriyasu had constructed a team well suited to upsetting teams who sought out control of possession, but less comfortable when asked to dictate the terms of an encounter.

His use in particular of Mitoma perhaps encapsulated this dichotomy; the Brighton winger’s introduction against Germany in 2022 helped transform the game, while his contribution against Spain, including the now-famous cross which led to Ao Tanaka’s winner, helped propel him onto the international stage. Moriyasu recognised his qualities early, in giving him an increasingly prominent role that gained instant reward.

However, deploying one of Japan’s most naturally gifted attacking players as a wing-back in subsequent years, has raised questions. Mitoma’s extraordinary ability to beat defenders, carry the ball into dangerous areas and create opportunities was often accompanied by substantial defensive responsibilities – rooting him ineffectively deep back in the defensive third. There was a legitimate argument that Japan were sacrificing some of his attacking threat by asking him to operate from deeper positions, particularly when the team were already struggling to create opportunities.

It was an effective tactical weapon, but perhaps not always the best way to maximise one of the most dangerous individual talents in Japanese, and at that point, world football.

Moriyasu has since tilted his approach, to evolve into a more proactive side ahead of 2026, yet the underlying questions about in-game management and tactical flexibility never entirely disappeared, with the ill-fated World Cup defeat to Brazil being the prime, and defining example. Having established a first-half lead, Japan struggled to maintain their initiative as Brazil increased the pressure, eventually conceding a late winner.

There was a familiar sense of a team capable of producing something dominant, but unable to sustain it when the circumstances demanded something different.

The missing piece of the puzzle

Moriyasu’s legacy should ultimately be judged against the tournaments Japan failed to win. The Asian Cup disappointments are perhaps the most obvious omission, despite the considerable focus on his World Cup campaigns. Defeat to Qatar in the 2019 final was an early setback, but the 2024 tournament was considerably more difficult to excuse.

Japan returned to the Gulf as considerable favourites, boasting a squad packed with European-based talent and arguably the strongest collection of players in the competition. Yet a fragile defence that failed to keep a clean sheet in any match, alongside defeats to Iraq in the group stage and Iran in the quarter-finals, exposed a side which never quite found its rhythm, or identity as the dominant side on the continent.

The absence of continental silverware across eight years in charge is a significant blemish. For a country which has won the Asian Cup a record four times, and with the resources and talent available to Moriyasu, these were opportunities which should have been converted.

Given the raised expectations during his tenure however, the World Cup arguably leaves the most long-lasting regrets.

Japan have now appeared in the knockout stages on five occasions, across 2002, 2010, 2018, 2022 and 2026, without winning a single match. Their defeats to Paraguay and Croatia on penalties, and the narrow loss to Belgium in 2018, have all provided their share of heartbreak. The latest defeat to Brazil, however, felt like the cruellest of missed opportunities for a generation which had been promising so much in the years previous.

The group stage victories over Germany and Spain may rightly be celebrated as Moriyasu’s crowning glories, however, they cannot indefinitely substitute for the achievement of actually winning when elimination is on the line.

A legacy still to be determined

There is, of course, an argument that Moriyasu’s contribution should be measured differently. He boasts the most impressive record of any Japanese coach before him. Japan have also risen almost 40 places in the FIFA rankings since his appointment, established themselves as one of the most consistently competitive international sides outside Europe and South America, and developed a generation of players who are increasingly comfortable competing at the highest level.

Those achievements should not be diminished by the absence of trophies, nor should the difficulties of navigating international tournaments be underestimated.

But there is a distinction between changing perceptions and delivering the achievements which those changing perceptions create expectations for.

Moriyasu has helped Japan believe they can beat anybody. His successor, Japan’s Under-23 coach Go Oiwa, will inherit a team expected to do exactly that. The next step is to turn those performances into sustained tournament success, to find the tactical flexibility and bravery to overcome opponents of different styles and, ultimately, to progress beyond the first knockout hurdle at a World Cup.

Saturday’s victory over Brazil was another reminder of what Japan are capable of. It was also a reminder of the remarkable progress made during Moriyasu’s tenure, even if the significance of such a result will always be tempered by its friendly status.

Whether he is remembered as the man who took Japan to the edge of something special, or the manager who couldn’t quite get them over it, will depend largely on what follows. For all the memorable victories, the celebrations and the growing belief in Japanese football, the most important milestone remains unclaimed.

Martin Lowe
Martin Lowe

Martin Lowe is a freelance football writer, having covered Asian football for over a decade. He has appeared on the BBC, Al Jazeera English and The Mirror, covering some of the biggest stories and developments in Asian football. He has been a senior contributor at The Asian Game website since its launch in 2019.

Articles: 114